The ratings are relative to the type of hotel this is: value. For stays like this, where I am by myself and don't need to look after a spouse or kids, I *really* appreciate the ability to get a room for such a reasonable rate.
Location is great if you want to explore Old Hangtown, Apple Hill, Gold Bug Mine, or about an hour drive to south Lake Tahoe area.
Service was prompt and friendly. The room had a fridge that worked great (practically brand new), and a microwave which I never plugged in but looked to be clean and modern.
Room was clean, water was nearly instantly hot and had good pressure. There was the expected amount of "manage to failure" maintenance in terms of steam damage to some paint in the bathroom, sad looking light fixture over the shower, older carpet, and painted duct tape around the heater/air conditioner unit. No complaints at this price point, but important to note for folks expecting a nicer experience (which will cost more).
The hotel is located very close Hwy 50. I was expecting a LOT more road noise given the location. The combination of blinds and privacy curtain did a really good job of blocking the noise.