I picked this place because some fool had previously rated it "wonderful." It was not. And it was definitely not worth what I paid for our one night stay.
The Cedar Gables is an old, creaky house with minimum accommodations. Okay, the bed was comfy, but that's about the only positive I can come up with. Too many oddities to mention, but I will note we could hear every footstep echoing loudly in the hall (could they try a rug?) the shower was terrible (barely a drip) and there wasn't a towel rack or hook to be found. Heck, they didn't even provide a box of kleenex! And if you're looking for a plush robe to lounge in your overpriced room, you're in the wrong place. My girlfriend joked the Cedar Gables would make for a better haunted house.
I will say that Tim the manager (and sole visible employee) was exceedingly nice, but his clothing and appearance was not so buttoned up clean - not a great first impression.
Overall, this would be an okay place to stay if the price was half their current asking rate, but even then you'd be left wondering.