The good: The rooms are clean and very comfortable with amazing views, just as advertised. The staff was helpful and friendly. Make sure you try one of Kostas amazing Greek salads.
The bad: There were a few instances of miscommunication and a blatant exploitation regarding a booking amendment. Gregory (the owner) deleted the messages where we had discussed said amendment and we had no way to prove it to the staff, so make sure you screenshot everything you discuss online.
Also, make sure to book your own transportation (you'll need it, since there's not much to do in walking distance and the bus can be a bit of a challenge). There are dozens of options available on the island and most are easy to find and book online. DO NOT go with the one they recommend. Having to deal with them was the lowest point of our holiday.
Overall, not the best value for money, but we still had a wonderful time.